Teaching Textbooks
<b><b>
Because it was a company on the market with mixed reviews, I researched Teaching Textbooks quite a bit before I purchased it last year. I knew that Jay Wile, my publisher, wasn’t fond of the Algebra program due to some missing concepts, and I’ve heard from others that it isn’t rigorous enough for college prep. I’ve also heard that TT has included all the missing concepts in the Pre Calculus program and that the students who have used this course in the past did very well on the SATs. <b><b><b><p>
<b><b>
As my daughter was not quite ready for Algebra, I perused the Pre Algebra program and found that it covered a lot of higher basic math concepts that we had not completely mastered. I also watched the video and loved the way that he explained some of the things my child was struggling to understand. I felt this review of basic mathematic concepts would help her to finally understand, as well as fill in any gaps we may have due to the fact that we skipped around to different math programs throughout the elementary years. <b>
<b>
So, here we are at the end of the year and I have some good news and some not so good news about the program.
<b>
<b>
The Good
<b>
<b>
First, let me say that my child (almost 14) had never ever before this year liked math. She, well, let’s just say that One and One did not equal two, it equaled tears and protests in our home over the last six or so years of doing math. Not only that, but the careless mistakes were the order of the day (year after year). She excelled in every other subject, almost to the genius level. Math, however, was like walking through thick mud, uphill.
<b>
<b>
Then, along comes Teaching Textbooks math. Wow. What can I say? What an easy year? When we finished devotions, the first subject she went for was math. She would plug in her little CD, listen and watch as Greg Sabouri explained the concept. Then she would do her work…happily, independently, really learning. Only a few times did she ever need intervention. She couldn’t remember the procedure for certain problems, and I would show her my ‘short cut’ for getting the answer. I’m sure Mr. Sabouri had a reason for having them take the long way to answer the equation, usually so that they understood the why behind the how. However, there were a couple of equations that the easy way was much faster and easier to remember. That happened probably twice, once with fractions, and once with percents. Overall, the basic math found in the first ¾ of the Pre Algebra book was well done and completely solved our chronic math woes.
<b>
<b>
I think the things that made this work so well were:
1. How easy it was to use. Popping in and finding your next lesson, watching it, then doing the problems and popping in the solutions CD to help with any problems that weren’t easy to solve was not complicated at all. It is designed with amazing facility.
2. The explanations he gave solidified many of the concepts she struggled to understand. It may have helped that she was “familiar” with all the concepts and had learned the algorithm at some point in the past. However, learning it from a new perspective was extremely helpful. I believe she finally understands math to a certain extent.
3. The independence that the program offers. The program is so streamlined and easy to use; each lesson gives just the right amount of new information and there isn’t too much work in the daily assignments. The child can check her answers and if she gets one wrong or struggles over a problem can actually pop in a CD to watch the problem being worked out. It’s so amazing.
Because of these things, I will be getting the program, beginning in sixth grade for my younger children. However, I will only use it for sixth and seventh grade math. I believe the Pre Algebra basic math section is probably a repeat of much of what was learned in 7th grade math. If more concepts are introduced, I may also get the Pre Algebra program and use it until the child reaches the actual algebra section of Pre Algebra (somewhere near the end of the book).
<b>
<b>
To summarize the good parts of this program: It has really helped transform my child from a math hater into a math liker (I didn’t say lover, but if she were a boy she might have turned into a math lover). I can only credit the transformation to this program. She loved it, felt successful all the way through the basic math portion of the book. I believe it filled in the gaps we may have left from our constant elementary math quandary over the last six years. I think it is fabulously designed and really makes it easy for the parent and student to get math done without any problems or tears every single day. Highly recommended for the basic math section.
<b>
<b>
Now, to the not so good.
<b>
<b>
When we did finally reach the end of the Pre Algebra book and began learning about negative numbers, things got hairy. I couldn’t understand what she didn’t understand because negative numbers makes perfect sense to me. He didn’t seem to be able to explain it in a way that a creative ballerina could really grasp. She would bring the book to me and I would explain it in my own words, but she still did not get it. When she finally understood a concept, there was not enough practice with it in the written lesson. She needed more practice with each new concept. There were about four equations total dealing with the new concept. This is probably due to the fact that it is a Pre Algebra course and not a true Algebra course. I have heard that the Algebra course has more than enough equations dealing with the new concept.
It seemed that we went through a similar routine with every new concept. Was she not ready for algebra? I thought this might be the case. However, I went to our local homeschool store and picked up the Keys To Algebra series. The way negative numbers were explained there turned on a light for her. Was it that she now had two explanations? I can’t be sure. Maybe if we had done Keys To first, she wouldn’t have understood until we listened to the TT explanation. I honestly don’t know.
<b>
<b>
I do know that if you asked me to write a review of TT in February or March, I would have gushed on and on about it. However, now, I am unable to do that. We had to put it down because the algebra in the Pre Algebra book is not explained in a way that rings a bell with my child and there isn’t enough practice. So, our experience with the algebra of TT has been a negative one. I cannot make a generalization about all their Algebra products. I also can’t say whether it was due to the fact that my daughter is not math minded, is not ready for algebra, or whether it was the explanations in the book.
<b>
<b>
So, as a recap, Teaching Textbooks basic math is superb in the TT Pre Algebra. I’m assuming it will also be in the fifth, sixth and seventh grade math books. I plan to get the sixth grade book for my younger children and work through the series until all the basic math is covered. I will not be using TT for Algebra, however.
I am seriously looking and leaning towards A Fresh Approach Algebra I for Algebra. I have the book and really like what I see. I also have the College Introductory Algebra book by Lial, and it doesn’t seem as easy to understand as A Fresh Approach.
<b>
<b>
I hope this was helpful!