Trixi's HomeEd Academy

This site is meant for sharing our homeschooling experiences in order to advise & encourage other homeschooling families.

Home Educating a Struggling Learner

November9

We removed our very active, yet highly intelligent 7-year old from private school in August 2010 because he was struggling with reading & writing due to his gross & fine motor skills foundation not having been addressed properly at a Gr. R level. He couldn’t skip skipping rope, had very little balance and neither could he cross hiss midlines, hence the learning problems. He is also a Right Brain Kinaesthetic as well as Visual Spatial learner & his learning styles are not catered for in most of our schools today.

“A mother’s first duty to her children is to secure for them a quiet and growing time, a full six years of passive receptive life, the waking part of it for the most part spent out in the fresh air.”

~ Charlotte Mason

And that’s where the “system” failed our little one quite miserably…

The school focused too early & too much on academics & neglected the motor skills as well as visual perception. Midline crossing & skipping, being very important skills for fluent reading were just 2 of many areas that were not addressed properly. Although he could memorise paragraphs, like a parrot, he struggled to read. He Aced his spelling tests but could not spell when writing sentences. These were just a few of the issues we’ve been working on together with his pre-school teacher to get him through Gr. 2. He was able to cope thus far due to his intelligence, but the struggling impacted his self-esteem very negatively & caused him to dislike school with a passion.

Although the school tried to address the problem with remedial (at additional cost to us as parents) & extra lessons, these showed very little success, but instead placed extra workload & repetition rather than addressing the foundation of the problem… hence we’ve took him back to Hettie Hen Playgroup after school twice a week since August 2009 so she could do physical activities & brain gym with him in order to get the brain development going. This showed huge improvement, but his backlog was so big that he still got very fidgety in class when he didn’t understand the tasks at hand. The other problem was that he was constantly stressed & tired, thus making the progress slow.

The following are pages where I found some very useful information to help my struggling learner:

We have applied many of the tips contained in these pages & together with the stress release, this has resulted in a huge improvement both in his abilities as well as his confidence.  ~ If you have a struggling learner, be sure to visit these pages & get some help to avoid yourself & your child some stress & frustration.

In-Their-Own-Way--Thomas-Armstrong-K"ADD seems like a matter of convenience to many adults who are in charge of "round kids" who don’t fit into the "square holes" of home and school. The label helps a teacher get a troublesome child out of a regular class and into a special education room, helps a parent get a drug prescription to set the problem right (instead of first considering other more fundamental changes, and even helps many students get more time to take tests and complete assignments in class. Unfortunately, though it’s the child who gets saddled with the disability label and has to go through school looked upon as less normal than the other kids. Nowhere in this litany of deficit, disability, and disedase is there the recognition that these children may learn very well IN THEIR OWN WAY." from In Their Own Way: Discovering and Encouraging Your Child’s Multiple Intelligences by Dr. Thomas Armstrong

We have one of those "round kids" that doesn’t fit into the "square holes", but refused the ADD label and instead, removed him from the "square hole" environment & today, just over a year later he’s flourishing & growing to become a confident student once again.

The-Fine-Line-Between-ADHD-and-Kines[1]I’m currently reading this book & am slowly starting to understand why our youngest had such a struggle at school. It seems he’s a right brain kinaesthetic learner. Keeping him interested in schoolwork is quite a challenge & I’m constantly having to change my strategies because he gets bored very easily. Thus far we have used the All-In-One Programme, Switched on Schoolhouse as well as Teaching Textbooks all of which were effective only for a while. I have recently had to change strategy again and now we’re using Time4Learning and loads of interactive educational PC games. Of course I’ve also added an Art tutor, because he enjoyed the few sessions for his art project last term so much.

image5[1]

image9

I have decided to take next few years one day at a time. We’ll continue with Time4Learning for as long as it works for him. In the interim I still have loads of links and books to work through in my quest to find ways & means to help him through.

I trust that in the near future we will be able to conquer this hatred for schoolwork & be able to restore his love for learning.

image14

image19

image24

 

Educating a Reluctant Learner

School in general is quite a mission in our home with both our boys. Although our eldest managed to cope quite well in school, we removed him because home running him up & down last year proved to disrupt home educating time with his brother. I have since discovered that his love for learning has been destroyed by school pressure.

Next year he will be doing 4 subjects with Alpha Omega Academy. As for the rest of the “normal” grade 9 curriculum I’m planning to do “Story of the World” with them and let him continue his technology lessons with his current tutor. I also want to try our some Woodworking lessons for them. Since they both love the Junior Engineering (JEFA) classes so much, I will let them continue those as well.

Here are some books I’ve found for teaching the child who hates school…

The Shut-Down Learner

Helping Your Academically Discouraged Child

Richard Selznick 

 

 

I Hate School

How to Help Your Child Love Learning

Cynthia Ulrich Tobias

 

Unfortunately I’ve been so busy helping my struggling learner that I still need to find the time to read through all these books. I’m thus not yet sure whether they contain any tips that will help with my boys.

I know however, during the next few years my greatest challenge will be restoring their love for learning. Yet, I still have no idea exactly how I’m going to achieve that.

Please visit my Educating a Struggling Learner page regularly as I will be posting regular updates when I find resources that work for my boys.

SAblogsbutton100

This post features on the South African Carnival of Homeschool Bloggers (SACH Bloggers) where South African home schoolers share experiences, ideas, philosophies and much more.  You can join the carnival too by heading to the South African Carnival of Homeschool Bloggers sign up page. We hope you enjoy the carnival as much as we have!

SA Home Schooling Blog Carnival #11

Trixi’s HomeEd Academy Page Updates:

I have added new links to several of my resource pages. Amended pages are indicated with ~*~ below.

Home Education Resources

SchoolTimePostDiv_thumb14_thumb

3 Comments to

“Home Educating a Struggling Learner”

  1. November 11th, 2011 at 8:02 pm      Reply Karen Says:

    Can you believe you’ve only been on this road for a little over a year?! You’ve amassed a wealth of information! Thanks for sharing!


  2. November 11th, 2011 at 7:26 pm      Reply Taryn Says:

    Your research is so encouraging, thank you!!!


  3. November 11th, 2011 at 6:59 am      Reply Linnie Lues Says:

    Hi Trys
    Thank you for sharing this very informative posting, on the 11th SACHS Blog Carnival!
    Blessings


Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Preschool Learning to Write | PreSchoolLearningToWrite

Email will not be published

Website example

Your Comment:

The Reasons for Our Journey into Home Education:

Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Although he managed to cope quite well in private school, he wasn't reaching his full potential because his love for learning had been destroyed.

Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Although very intelligent, he was struggling through school & hated it. He was always tired and homeworktime was a major frustration for both of us.

Read more here....

YouVersion

Hello Mornings Button Inspired to Action Button

South African Carnival of Homeschool Bloggers (SACH Blogs) where South African home schoolers can share experiences, ideas, philosophies and much more.  You can join the carnival too by heading to the South African Carnival of Homeschool Bloggers sign up page. We hope you enjoy the carnival as much as we have!

Become a SchoolhouseTeachers.com Member at just $5.95 per month

View Member Benefits

Learning Styles

Homeschooling South Africa: The Homeschool HUB

CurrClick

CurrClick

RSS Dad’s Perspective on Homeschooling

  • Introduction December 18, 2010
    I have been thinking of homeschooling as an option for our children for about 3 years, but I could not get the breakthrough in our thinking as a family until this year when we found that my youngest son still had issues with his education foundation. We approached the private school my children attended with […]
    Clive Schwartz

Cultural Exchange

Worldwide Culture Swap

Little Red Farm


RSS Peace Haven ~ My Family Blog

  • Tollgate dilemma. May 8, 2012
    Check the date on the first photo : 23 April 2012 Wasn't this what the public predicted would happen ??????  BB 65 PN GP     1ST  car   BB  65  PN GP       2 nod car   BB  65  PN  GP    MOTOR BIKE     The FUN has JUST BEGUN. (and some of our worst nightmares.) 3 Different vehicles with the same registration number. Who will be Paying for this account?   […]
    Patrizia (a.k.a. Trys / Trixi) Schwartz
  • Amazing Photos January 28, 2012
    The world's highest chained carousel, located in Vienna, the height of 117 meters.Thor's Well - "the gates of the dungeon." Cape Perpetua, Oregon. At moderate tide and strong surf, flowing water creates a fantastic landscapeEmerald Lake in the crater of an extinct volcano. Tongariro National Park - New ZealandRestaurant on a cliff on the […]
    Patrizia (a.k.a. Trys / Trixi) Schwartz
  • Finding the Fun January 15, 2012
    From the YouVersion mobile "Joice Meyer: Promises for your Everyday Life - a Devotional" Bible reading plan.Want to hear a funny story? I've got a lot of them, and they come from things that happened in my ordinary, everyday life. Now, I wasn't laughing when those stories were in the making, but I'm glad I can laugh about them now. F […]
    Patrizia (a.k.a. Trys / Trixi) Schwartz

RSS Trixi’s Digi-Scraps ~ My Hobby

  • Happy New Year!!! December 30, 2011
    Life is not measured by the number of breaths we take... but by the moments that take your breath away! May all your days be breathtaking in 2012 & may you be surrounded by true friends, loads of love & tons of happiness... Wishing you and your loved ones a very blessed & Happy New Year!!! Just One RequestDear Master for this coming yearJust one […]
    Patrizia (a.k.a. Trys / Trixi) Schwartz
  • ~::~ Christmas Gifts for Everyone ~::~ December 22, 2011
    Wishing all a Blessed Christmas, to you and the family. Spend this time with loved ones sharing All The good things God has done in your Life The best of Yahoo Groups @ Your Inbox Daily                         .-"""-.    .-"""-.                       /       '..'       \                .-"""-;    .- […]
    Patrizia (a.k.a. Trys / Trixi) Schwartz
  • MyMemories FREE Digital ScrapBooking Software Give Away! October 8, 2011
    Using this software, anyone can create digital scrapbooks, photobooks, cards, calendars and gifts without having to buy expensive and complicated software programs. Visit Amazon to view reviews received. My Memories Suite version 2 software is a complete digital scrapbooking solution that provides a powerful set of creative tools and multiple sharing options […]
    Patrizia (a.k.a. Trys / Trixi) Schwartz

CurrClick

homeschool math online

eHomeEducation

Get serious about learning guitar

Learn & Master Series

Live Guitar Lessons

I was born in Bergish Gladbach, Germany, immigrated to South Africa at age 5. I have a wonderful husband & 2 beautiful boys. I’ve been a stay-at-home mom since August 2005. I love taking photos. I discovered scrapping in 2007 & am now totally addicted to digital scrapbooking.

To-Be-Educated-000-Page-1

We have a very active, yet highly intelligent 7 year old, who has been struggling through school for the past 2 years. It has recently come to our attention that his gross & fine motor skills foundation has not been addressed properly at a Gr. R level. He is also a kinaesthetic, visual spatial & active learner & this learning style is not catered for in most of our schools today. He hated school, was always tired & homework time was a major frustration for both of us.

“A mother’s first duty to her children is to secure for them a quiet and growing time, a full six years of passive receptive life, the waking part of it for the most part spent out in the fresh air.” ~ Charlotte Mason

And that’s where the “system” failed our little one quite miserably…

Already in Grade R we called on Tannie Hettie to help, because by end of August, he still didn’t know his alphabet. Within 3 weeks with 1 hour at Hettie, twice a week, he knew half of it & by the end of the year he had it all. During this time hubby started suggesting home education, but I resisted because I just didn’t feel confident that I would be able to do it. I figured, I’d probably strangle him in a week because we were always frustrated & irritable when doing homework.

But then in Grade 1 teacher insisted he needed speech therapy, so that’s what he got. But it didn’t end there, because speech therapy just caused more confusion. After 3 months the teacher figured we should switch him over to remedial lessons instead. During this time of course it was suggested that he does extra lessons. Needless to say, the remedial  lessons (at additional cost to us as parents) produced no results & extra lessons were just adding to his stress.  I went back to Hettie. Once again, he went to her twice a week for an hour after school. But the poor kid was so exhausted, by the time I got back to fetch him she’d mention he was just too tired to really work with, although she did still manage to produce results. At the end of Grade 1 we decided to cancel remedial as well as extra lessons & depended on Hettie entirely to help him. However, he was still tired after school & extra murals, so we reduced it to once a week, but instead of giving more work, she would work with him doing his homework so that he didn’t still have to do that when he got home. It helped a lot, but left little time for her to work with him on movement & motor skills.

With a push & a shove, we managed to get him through grade 1,  but the struggle didn’t end there. He continued to go to Hettie once a week & was making good improvement, but whilst working with him doing his homework one day I noticed that he would “read” words on one page but wasn’t able to recognise them on another. That’s when we realised something was seriously wrong…He kept on insisting that teacher would read to them first & then they would read. What they didn’t realise though, was that he could memorise a page hearing it only once.  he became more & more fidgety in class.

After my neck operation in June, hubby insisted we look into home education as an option, even if just for a short term to get him up to standard, thus I took the school holiday & started some serious investigation in to home education. After the holiday his teacher (a very highly qualified remedial teacher at that) once again requested that we to give him medication for his “lack of concentration”.

Finally we decided to let Hettie stop working with him on his homework. I asked her to go back to the basics & find the problem. Turns out he couldn’t skip a skipping rope, tie his shoe laces or cross his midlines & he remembered nothing of what he should have learnt in Grade R. It seems the school focused too early & too much on academics & neglected the motor skills as well as visual perception. Midline crossing & skipping, being very important skills for fluent reading are just 2 of many areas that have not been addressed properly. Although he can memorise paragraphs, like a parrot, he struggles to read. He Aced his spelling tests but couldn’t spell them when writing sentences. These are just a few of the issues we’ve been working on together with his pre-school teacher to get him through Gr. 2. Up to now he’s been able to cope with his intelligence, but the struggling has impacted his self-esteem very negatively & caused him to dislike school with a passion & homework for us, became an endless battle.

Although the school tried to address the problem with remedial & extra lessons, these showed very little success, but instead placed extra workload & repetition rather than addressing the foundation of the problem… hence we’ve took him back to Hettie Hen Playgroup twice a week since August last year so she could do physical activities & brain gym with him in order to get the brain development going. This has shown huge improvement, but his backlog is so big that he still gets very fidgety in class when he doesn’t understand the tasks at hand.

We met with the principal to discuss the problem & check what they’d do to resolve it, but his reply was that they’d support us in whatever we decided. In the end the teacher was expecting myself & Hettie to work at resolving the foundational problems, in order for him to pass his grade. By then I was at the end of my tether. I think I hated homework time more than he did. Due to the amount of stress caused by school pressure, Hettie & I felt it would be more productive doing this if we removed him from school & this is were our journey in to home education began…

“Every student can learn. Just not on the same day or in the same way.” ~ George Evans

We know now that Misha’s just a normal active little boy who’s trying to cope with a situation that’s way beyond his control. We were just blessed with one of those “round kids” that doesn’t fit into the “square holes”, but refused to accept the labels, & instead, removed him from the “square hole” environment & since he’s been home his reading has improved although he still hates it. He’s getting A’s on his Smart Tutor English & Maths Lessons but absolutely hates filling out the worksheets. He’s a much happier & healthier child, but still has a very long way to go… & yes, three months later both of us are still very much alive, because the stress release on both sides has enabled me to be more patient & tolerable.

We’ve recently registered him with Le-Amen Education Centre in Ruimsig & have pulled him out of school on Friday. What I like about Le-Amen is that they are registered with the Gauteng education department and they supply the curriculum at very reasonable prices. The kids’ work books have to be handed in 3 times a year to be monitored by qualified teachers & at the end of the school year they issue school reports to the children. Both parent & kids are monitored & at matric level they write the same IEB exams as the private schools.

We used the first week to let him destress & deschool. In the interim he’ll be using Time4learning online curriculum to put the fun back into learning. Then we’ll continue his schooling, but will also have to go back as far as Gr. R in order to address his foundation. I just hope we caught it on time to repair the damage & that we will be able to help him reach his full potential in life.

“Mothers write on the hearts of their children what the hand of time can’t erase.” (Unknown)

When I look at the amount of kids in our schools that end up in remedial & extra lessons, I cannot help but wonder how many of them are highly intelligent kids, like Misha, whose foundations have been proved lacking & due to that will be struggling through school for the rest of their lives. I just cannot understand how it is possible in today’s day & age, with all the knowledge available to our teachers regarding the importance of physical activities being the foundation to develop brain functions in our little ones that they still let them sit cooped up in classrooms with academics all day at such a young age. Our little ones should be playing more & learning less, the academics will follow as soon as the body is sorted.

I must confess, I’ve spent months stressing about Misha’s situation & was fuming, when the teacher’s plan to resolve this issue was aimed at Misha’s preschool teacher & myself addressing the foundation in order to get him through Gr. 2. As far as I was concerned, we pay expensive school fees & he shouldn’t have been in this situation in the first place. Today, however, I can honestly say the burden’s lifted & I have peace in my heart that we’ve made the right decision for our boys.

“When we forgive someone, it doesn’t make them right or justify what they have done. It releases them into God’s hands so He can deal with them. Forgiveness is actually the best revenge because it not only sets us free from the person we forgive, but it sets us free to move into all God has for us.” ~ Stormie O’Martian

The school & their staff have been forgiven. I’m letting go & we’re moving forward. I pray for wisdom to make the right decisions in order to continuously guide our sons into reaching their full potential.

20 August 2010

* Smile *

Our eldest, Jesse, has had a solid Grade R foundation because he graduated with Hettie & didn’t start off at private school like Misha. He seems to have coped quite well in private school & doesn’t have any learning problems, but we felt it impractical to leave one in school & home educate the other, so we gave him the choice to stay or come home. He eagerly chose to come home & I have noticed that school has killed his love for learning too, yet he was still getting good grades.

Although he was achieving good results, he wasn’t reaching his full potential because his love for learning had been destroyed.

Ever since the decision was made, both our boys have changed drastically. They have become much more loveable, relaxed & no longer fight on a daily basis. They actually get along much better & I find them play-wrestling almost on a daily basis. Although our home education journey was only meant to be for a season to get Misha up to standard, we have since decided that they will never ever be exposed to those “square environments” again…

Our biggest challenge for now is how to repair the damage & restore their love for learning, so please if you have any tips/suggestions at all, please leave a comment.

19 December 2010

* Smile *

Blog Awards ~ Thank You!

HomeSchool Lounge

THL

Homeschool Toolbar

Try ClickN READ & ClickN SPELL Today!

Preschool Learning Extravaganza